There are several pros and cons of both plumber's putty and rubber gasket. The former is petroleum-based and stains free, while the latter is easier to install. Candu Plumbing of Chatsworth blog: what are Chatsworth plumbers? It also lasts for a long time, usually about 20 years. Let's discuss these pros and cons to make an informed decision.

It's petroleum-based

Plumbers putty is a clay-like substance that is commonly used in the installation of plumbing fixtures, such as faucets and sinks. It is also used in pop-up drain fittings for tubs. However, some types of plumber's putty can stain porous materials. In that case, it is recommended to opt for an oil-free alternative.

Petroleum-based plumbers putty is more flexible and pliable than rubber gaskets made from plastics. While they are both good for a variety of jobs, you should avoid using plumbers putty on plastic materials, as it can damage your piping system. In addition, plumbers putty can get into your food if it comes into contact with it, so be sure to use silicone-based plumbers putty if possible.

Another reason why petroleum-based plumbers putty is better is that it is easier to apply. While putty is messy initially, it gets better over time. However, it's not advisable to splice sections of the putty rope since it can cause leaks.

It's stain-free

Stain-free plumber's putties help prevent stains on natural surfaces. They are designed for use on frames, faucets, basket strainers, and other natural surfaces. Plus, they clean up quickly and easily. This product has earned the trust of plumbing professionals for over a century.

Oatey Stain-Free Plumber's Putty is a non-staining, oil-free plumber's putty that is safe for natural surfaces. It provides a waterproof seal between two rigid surfaces and is easy to clean. Its patented formulation means that it will never stain natural surfaces.

This 9-ounce bottle of plumber's putty is designed for a variety of applications. It is a great product to have on hand. Its non-staining formula allows it to stick to most surfaces. However, it can be hard to remove from wood and painted surfaces.

Stain-free plumber's putties are the best for a variety of surfaces. However, if you are working with stainless steel, you should find one that is specifically made for stainless steel.

It's easier to install

Plumbers putty is a highly recognizable clay-like substance that's typically used in the installation of plumbing fixtures. It's used in faucets, sinks, and pop-up drain fittings on tubs and showers. But it has a downside – it can stain porous materials. If that's a concern, you should try one of the many oil-free types of putty available in the market.

Plumbers putty is not difficult to use and comes in small plastic tubs that can be easily carried in your tool bag. To apply it, simply roll a small amount of putty into a long rope or snake and drape it over the plumbing fixture. Make sure to apply pressure but not too much. Otherwise, extra pressure will ruin the putty's shape and may even cause a leak.

While silicone is a great option for plumbing applications, plumbers putty is a better choice for drains and other plumbing fixtures. Silicone hardens over time, making it more difficult to remove. This makes plumber's putty a better option for drain pipes, where it stands up better to long-term exposure to water. Also, plumber's putty is easier to remove and replace if it becomes too hard or dried.

It's better for long-term exposure to water

Although plumbers putty is less expensive than a rubber gasket, it is not as durable as a rubber gasket. While it may be easier to work with, it cannot hold paint. As a result, the putty may not seal properly. Nevertheless, it is still an excellent choice for plumbing fixtures.

Plumbers putty is a clay-like substance that dries hard with time. Its consistency is soft when first applied. Different brands use different formulas, though the main ingredients are powdered clay and linseed oil. There are even products that are stain-free.

Plumbers putty is softer and less rigid than silicone sealants. Silicones are also more water-resistant. However, unlike putty, silicones cannot be remolded after they dry. Silicone is also UV-resistant and waterproof.

Plumbers putty is ideal for sealing plumbing parts because it is easy to apply and remove. It also hardens into a more durable seal, making it a better choice for drains and pipes. It is also more traditional than silicone and is a popular choice for many people.